straxiom.
Corporate tax

Netherlands · Court decision

Dutch court denies reorganisation transfer-tax relief where fund investors hold the economic interest

Published 2 min read

On 6 November 2026, the Netherlands Supreme Court delivered judgment ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1814, ruling that a common fund manager’s legal ownership of shares did not establish the group relationship required for an internal-reorganisation exemption from real estate transfer tax.

Official document:
Hoge Raad judgment 25/01249, ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1814; Wet op belastingen van rechtsverkeer Article 15(1)(h); Uitvoeringsbesluit belastingen van rechtsverkeer Article 5b
Development date:
2026-11-06

Two funds shared a manager, not their economic owners

The dispute concerned a company within an international financial-services group. A common manager legally owned the shares in companies associated with two real estate funds without legal personality. Investors acquired transferable units giving them proportionate claims to each fund’s assets and income. No investor held 90% or more of the units. During the liquidation of one fund, the taxpayer acquired shares in a Dutch real-estate entity and claimed the internal-reorganisation exemption after paying transfer tax.[1]

Economic exposure determines the group relationship

The exemption relied on Article 15(1)(h) of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act and Article 5b of its implementing decree. The Supreme Court held that a qualifying group relationship requires the parent to have all or nearly all the economic interest in the relevant subsidiary shares. That means bearing all or nearly all the risk of changes in value and loss of the shares, and enjoying their proceeds. Legal ownership alone does not establish that interest, even where the company has only one class of shares.[1]

The investors’ rights prevented relief

Here, the investors bore a significant part of the economic risk and enjoyed the corresponding returns. The common manager therefore did not hold all or nearly all the economic interest. Nor did the companies form a qualifying group with any individual investor, because none held at least 90% of the units. The court reversed the lower decisions and denied the exemption for the acquisition.[1]

Review contractual rights as well as share registers

For fund and multinational reorganisations involving Dutch property entities, a common legal shareholder is not sufficient evidence of the required group relationship. Review the fund contracts, rights to proceeds and allocation of economic risks before relying on relief. The judgment does not create a new tax rate or filing deadline. It also found no established transaction protected by Article 5 of the Capital Duty Directive in this case; it should not be read as deciding every possible claim under that directive.[1]

Official sources

  1. [1] Hoge Raad judgment ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1814, case 25/01249

    Hoge Raad / Raad voor de Rechtspraak · Document date: 2026-11-06

    Official public XML: judgment and publication metadata 6 November 2026; paragraphs 2.1–2.4 (fund structure and acquisition), 4.2 (economic-interest test), 4.4.2–4.4.5 (application, Article 5 qualification and disposition). Entire XML recovered and read through normal HTTPS download after web-parser access failures; initial incorrect ECLI= parameter returned HTTP 400, corrected id= endpoint returned HTTP 200 and 17,278 bytes. The 16 November metadata-modification instant is not treated as a new legal event.

Read our editorial standards or report a correction.