straxiom.
Customs and trade

European Union · Court decision

EU court excludes lower-triglyceride fish-oil products from CN 1516

Published 2 min read

On 11 November 2026, the EU General Court held in Fischölimporteur (T-701/25) that Combined Nomenclature heading 1516 does not cover the fish-oil products before it.

Official document:
T-701/25, Fischölimporteur, ECLI:EU:T:2026:743
Development date:
2026-11-11

The products contained substantially less triglyceride than natural fish oil

The products were made from concentrated omega-3 fatty acids derived from crude fish oil, contained 60.5% to 83.7% re-esterified triglycerides, and otherwise consisted mainly of mono- and diglycerides generated as re-esterification by-products.[1]

The national classification dispute continues

The dispute arose from imports from Chile in 2016 and 2017. The importer declared the products under CN code 1516 10 90, with a preference claim that produced a nil duty rate. German customs instead classified them under CN code 2106 90 92 and assessed 8.9% preferential duty. The General Court answered the German Federal Fiscal Court’s preliminary question; it did not itself finally classify the goods under heading 2106 or determine the national appeal.[1]

Heading 1516 requires composition comparable with natural oils

The Court said classification must turn on the product’s objective characteristics and the wording and notes of the Combined Nomenclature. Heading 1516 covers animal or vegetable fats and oils that are, among other things, re-esterified but not further prepared. Re-esterified fats and oils must contain triglycerides at a level comparable with animal fats and oils in their natural state, which generally contain well above 90%. Products containing 90% re-esterified triglycerides can still meet that description, and the evidence included a German binding tariff ruling for a product reaching 96.5%. By contrast, the 60.5%–83.7% range was substantially below the natural comparator.[1][3]

The ruling is product-specific, not a universal percentage test

The judgment did not create a universal 85% or 90% threshold. It rejected an argument based on the 15% milk-fat rule in Chapter 15 because that rule is limited to food preparations containing products of heading 0405. The operative conclusion is confined to products with the composition before the Court. The reasoning builds on Golden Omega, which held that fish oil in ethyl-ester form was not a fat or oil of heading 1516 because it was not composed principally of glycerol-and-fatty-acid esters in triglyceride form.[1][2]

Importers should reassess composition evidence and customs codes

The 2026 Combined Nomenclature retains the same heading 1516 description. EU importers of concentrated omega-3 and similar re-esterified oils should retain compositional testing, manufacturing records and binding-tariff-information analysis, and reassess codes, origin preferences and duty exposure where triglyceride levels or by-products resemble those in the judgment. The ruling changes no return or payment deadline; its consequence arises when the correct CN or TARIC code and customs duty are declared at import.[1][3][4]

Official sources

  1. [1] Fischölimporteur, T-701/25, ECLI:EU:T:2026:743

    General Court of the European Union · Document date: 2026-11-11

    Official CELEX identity and judgment metadata; numbered judgment paragraphs 19–27, 28–39, 40–48 and operative part were recovered through a lawful transcription linked to this official CELEX identity after the direct EUR-Lex body returned an access error.

  2. [2] Golden Omega, C-388/23, ECLI:EU:C:2024:1022

    Court of Justice of the European Union · Document date: 2024-12-12

    Paragraphs 29–46 and operative part on fish oil in ethyl-ester form and heading 1516.

  3. [3] Council Regulation (EEC) No 2658/87 on the tariff and statistical nomenclature

    European Union · Document date: 2026-01-01

    Annex I, Chapter 15, heading 1516 and CN subheadings 1516 10 10 and 1516 10 90; consolidated current text.

  4. [4] Commission publishes the 2026 Combined Nomenclature

    European Commission · Document date: 2025-10-31

    Commission notice identifying Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1926 and application from 1 January 2026.

Read our editorial standards or report a correction.