Australia · Court decision
Australia finds tax-loss scheme adviser liable as a promoter
On 16 November 2026, Australia’s Federal Court declared that an adviser contravened the promoter rules through a tax-loss access scheme involving trusts and a loss company.
- Official document:
- Commissioner of Taxation v White (Liability) [2026] FCA 1707; Taxation Administration Act 1953, Schedule 1 sections 290-50, 290-60 and 290-65; Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 section 100A
- Development date:
- 2026-11-16
A liability decision, not a penalty order
Commissioner of Taxation v White concerned arrangements designed to redirect trust income to a company with accumulated losses. The company received a fee while economic value passed elsewhere. The court found promoter liability; penalties and remaining issues were left for later management.[1]
Advice and encouragement are different
The judgment applied Schedule 1 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953. Section 290-60 distinguishes independent advice from substantial encouragement for consideration. The adviser’s implementation and defence of the arrangements went beyond merely advising. Section 100A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 was sufficient to defeat the contention that the intended benefit was reasonably arguable.[1]
Governance relevance
For groups using Australian trusts and loss entities, the practical issue is the quality and independence of advice, not a new deduction or filing rule. Review adviser incentives and the commercial and tax analysis supporting comparable arrangements. Monitor later orders or appeals before treating the liability judgment as the final procedural outcome.[1]
Official sources
- [1] Commissioner of Taxation v White (Liability) [2026] FCA 1707
Federal Court of Australia · Document date: 2026-11-16
Order 1; paragraphs 1–8, 12–25, 371–397, 414–448 and 450–469. Liability only; historical statutory wording is reproduced in the reasons.