New Zealand · International tax development
New Zealand private ruling allows service-related option cancellation deduction
On 9 November 2026, Inland Revenue published a private-ruling summary allowing deductions for particular share-option cancellation payments after an asset sale. The result depends on the payments’ service-related character, not merely their timing.
- Official document:
- TDS 26/19; Income Tax Act 2007 sections DV 27(6), DA 1, DA 2(1) and YA 1
- Development date:
- 2026-11-09
The company cancelled unvested, unexercised options after selling its business assets. Participants included employees, contractors and directors. The asset-sale agreement did not require cancellation or payment. The Tax Counsel Office’s 23 June decision, now summarised publicly, accepted a deduction under section DA 1 without the section DA 2(1) capital limitation, subject to conditions: payments recognised ordinary current or past services, the options did not reward facilitation of the sale, and management’s sale involvement was incidental to existing roles.[1]
That distinction matters to acquisition and disposal planning. Existing interpretation statement IS 24/07 explains that section DV 27(6) treats the employing or contracting company as having expenditure for qualifying employee-share-scheme benefits. This does not automatically establish deductibility: the income-earning nexus and general limitations still matter. Tax-law employee status is also wider than an ordinary employment label and can include some recipients of schedular payments. A group should identify the actual employing or contracting entity rather than assume the share issuer obtains the deduction.[2]
In the new summary, the DV 27(6) conclusion was limited to statutory employees. Cash cancellation payments to non-employees were nevertheless expenditure under ordinary principles, with their deduction assessed separately. This is not a ruling that every contractor benefit or transaction-related payment is deductible. The publication is informational, may omit relevant facts and is neither binding on other taxpayers nor protection against tax, penalty or interest.[1]
Payroll treatment is a separate workstream. Inland Revenue’s existing public instructions require employment information for an employee’s ESS benefit and withholding where it is cash-settled. The private summary creates no new filing date. Before cancelling options, groups should retain scheme and sale documents, identify recipients and the payment’s purpose, and assess both corporate deduction and payroll treatment; a favourable deduction conclusion does not discharge employer obligations.[1][2][3]
Official sources
- [1] TDS 26/19 — Share option cancellation
Inland Revenue Tax Counsel Office · Document date: 2026-11-09
PDF pages 1–6, paragraphs 1–21: decision 23 June 2026; publication 9 November 2026; facts, employee-only DV 27(6) deeming, ordinary cash expenditure, service-related conditions and capital limitation. Informational private-ruling summary, not general guidance or a binding opinion.
- [2] IS 24/07 — Deductions for parties to employee share schemes
Inland Revenue · Document date: 2024-08-22
Pages 2–10, paragraphs 3–31: statutory ESS definition, tax employee status, DV 27 text and general-permission/limitations relationship. Edition dated 22 August 2024, freshly read as official statutory-background alternative after the current DA legislation page returned 403.
- [3] Deducting tax from employee share scheme benefits
Inland Revenue · Document date: 2026-10-28
Main text, cash-settled ESS benefits and employment-information requirements. Last updated 28 October 2026; existing payroll treatment, not a new obligation created by TDS 26/19.