United Kingdom · Court decision
UK court separates CGT purpose from income-tax advantage on share buybacks
On 12 November 2026, the Court of Appeal dismissed HMRC’s appeal in Osmond, distinguishing a capital-gains-tax purpose from the separate income-tax purpose required by the transactions-in-securities rules.
- Official document:
- HMRC v Osmond and Allen [2026] EWCA Civ 1440; Income Tax Act 2007 sections 684 and 687
- Development date:
- 2026-11-12
Two shareholders had received £20 million through company share buybacks intended to preserve Enterprise Investment Scheme disposal relief. HMRC sought income-tax counteraction. Although an income-tax advantage existed under section 687 of the Income Tax Act 2007, that consequence did not establish the main-purpose requirement in section 684(1)(c).[1]
The judgment concerns the statutory version applicable to 2014–15. The court distinguished purpose from effect: an actual main purpose of avoiding income tax remains caught even where the precise saving has not been calculated. It did not grant blanket protection for buybacks or reorganisations.[1]
For teams planning shareholder exits or capital reorganisations, the practical implication is to preserve contemporaneous evidence of transaction objectives and analyse the applicable statutory version. Do not treat a favourable capital-gains outcome alone as either proof of an income-tax avoidance purpose or assurance that all anti-avoidance rules are satisfied.[1]
Official sources
- [1] HMRC v Osmond and Allen [2026] EWCA Civ 1440
Court of Appeal; official National Archives judgment · Document date: 2026-11-12
Paragraphs 1–9 (facts/outcome), 10–20 (2014–15 statutory version and reproduced ITA 2007 ss.684/687), 35–57 (purpose/effect), 76–78 (unanimous dismissal). Later statutory versions and other anti-avoidance rules are not determined.