Germany · Court decision
Germany denies tax-group treatment after first-year profit-transfer failure
On 19 November 2026, Germany’s Federal Fiscal Court published two judgments confirming that failure to implement a profit-transfer agreement in its first applicable year can defeat corporate and trade-tax group recognition, despite later performance or a retrospective contractual change.
- Official document:
- BFH I R 18/23 and I R 18, 19/25, judgments of 14 October 2026; KStG section 14(1), sentence 1, number 3 and section 17; GewStG section 2(2)
- Development date:
- 2026-11-19
German fiscal unity, or Organschaft, allows qualifying group income to be attributed rather than each company being taxed separately. Section 14(1), sentence 1, number 3 of the Corporate Income Tax Act requires a profit-transfer agreement lasting at least five years and actual performance throughout its applicable term. Section 17 extends relevant requirements to GmbH subsidiaries; section 2(2) of the Trade Tax Act links trade-tax recognition to those rules.[2][3]
In I R 18/23, the agreement applied from 2012 but was performed only from 2013. Five consecutive years of later performance did not cure the missing first year, even within a longer contractual term. Minimum duration and actual implementation are separate requirements.[2]
The joined cases concerned an agreement originally applying from 2019 but performed only from 2020. A 2023 amendment retrospectively moved its start and minimum term to 2020–2024. That did not restore recognition for the disputed 2020 year: no statutory mechanism authorised retrospective cure of the complete first-year failure.[3]