Germany · Court decision
Germany clarifies rooftop solar’s effect on property trade-tax relief
On 19 November 2026, Germany’s Federal Fiscal Court published judgment III R 12/25, clarifying when rooftop solar rights jeopardise extended property trade-tax relief and why a separate tax-group correction may still be needed.
- Official document:
- BFH III R 12/25, judgment 13 August 2026, published 19 November 2026; GewStG section 9 number 1 sentence 2 and section 2(2) sentence 2
- Development date:
- 2026-11-19
Section 9, number 1, sentence 2 of the Trade Tax Act permits an extended deduction for qualifying own-property management income. A commercial business split (Betriebsaufspaltung) can exclude it, including between corporate members of a tax group.[2]
The property owner granted rooftop-use rights to an indirectly wholly owned service company. That company mainly managed buildings and also handled group financing and cash pooling. Solar generation represented only 0.38% of its turnover in 2009 and 0.71% in 2010, and was not essential to its other activities.[1]
Contractual rights can constitute an essential operating asset; owning the roof is not the only relevant arrangement. But essentiality is assessed from the operating company’s overall business, not the landlord’s or wider group’s perspective. On these facts, the rooftop rights were insufficiently significant to create the required operational link.[2]
That conclusion did not settle the entire deduction. For 2009 and 2010, the court remitted the case to check intragroup rental expenses, income and trade-tax additions. Section 2(2), sentence 2 requires avoiding unjustified group-level relief where corresponding amounts already offset. Rejection of a business split therefore does not guarantee the full extended deduction.