United States · Court decision
US Tax Court corrects Otay basis analysis but preserves deduction denial
On 19 November 2026, the US Tax Court partly granted reconsideration in Otay Project LP, withdrawing part of its partnership-basis analysis but preserving a deduction disallowance of more than USD 713 million on independent economic-substance grounds.
- Official document:
- Otay Project LP v Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-120, docket 6819-20; IRC section 743(b); Tax Court Rules 161 and 155
- Development date:
- 2026-11-19
The supplemental opinion concerns a section 743(b) partnership basis adjustment arising in 2007 and a deduction exceeding USD 743 million claimed on termination and liquidation on 3 October 2012. The earlier opinion sustained disallowance of USD 713,759,615 and independently held that the transactions lacked economic substance.[1]
The reconsideration motion challenged the technical basis calculation, not the separate economic-substance conclusion. Rule 161 reconsideration serves to correct substantial errors of law or fact; it is not a fresh opportunity to repeat rejected arguments or introduce new theories.[1]
The court confirmed that the partner had a positive section 704(b) book capital account and no unconditional obligation to restore a negative account. It withdrew Part II.B of T.C. Memo. 2026-21 and declined to decide whether the section 743(b) adjustment and resulting deduction were calculated correctly, because that question was unnecessary to the outcome.[1]
The correction did not establish a deduction entitlement. The court maintained its independent conclusion that the transactions were shams lacking economic substance and continued to sustain the USD 713,759,615 disallowance. An appropriate order will issue and a decision will be entered under Rule 155; the petitioner preserved its right to appeal.